Fakir Shah

Zulkarnain Saer and the missing Right of Reply

Saer is one of the few Bangladeshi journalists who has a wikipedia page. He is a journalist for Aljazeera and several western media outlets have published his pieces. So, he has credentials which are unparalleled among Bangladeshi journalists. 

Since he is working for Aljazeera, an established news outlet, you would have thought that he is a journalist who maintains professionalism when he publishes anything anywhere. But one troubling aspect of the journalism of Saer is that he just publishes his reports without either seeking comment from the accused/the person affected by the reports or failing to mention that he sought comments from those people. 

Weekly note - 16 March 2025

So the government has identified people who laundered more than 200 crore. The question I have is why they are fixated on 200 crore? How did they make the decision that they would not go below 200 crore? How come 200 crore becomes the magic figure? 

Awami support or anti Jamaat

Recently, Shafiqul Alam, Press Secretary to the Chief Advisor of the interim government, posted a picture on Facebook of himself throwing dirt into a dustbin featuring a portrait of Sheikh Hasina at the Bangla Academy on the first day of the Ekushey Book Fair. His post faces some criticism from a number of people. One of the people criticising the post is Anu Mohammad, the environmentalist and activist. Now, you may find it difficult to fathom why, of all people, Anu Mohammad would criticize the post. After all, he was constantly criticizing the Hasina government during the last BAL administration and was a thorn in the side of the BAL government. 

Zulkarnain Saer and the freedom of press

Saer is a Bangladeshi journalist working for Al Jazeera. His role during the July uprising is beyond commendable. He inside information via his facebook page informed people at a time when information was scarce. But his stance on press freedom and accusation of setting narrative raise the question - what kind of press freedom and freedom of speech does Saer believe? 

Recently, Charlotte Jacquemart , a Senior Business Editor for Swiss Public Radio, Switzerland, published an op-ed in the Dhaka Tribune. In the op-ed she questioned the imprisonment of a number of journalists in Bangladesh. Saer attacked the op-ed and Ms. Jacquemart in a facebook post -  𝐌𝐞𝐝𝐢𝐚 𝐅𝐫𝐞𝐞𝐝𝐨𝐦: 𝐋𝐢𝐞𝐬, 𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐚𝐠𝐚𝐧𝐝𝐚, 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐀𝐫𝐭 𝐨𝐟 𝐒𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐀𝐦𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐢𝐚. In the post one of his comments is - 

Some thoughts on the yet to be made July proclamation

The leaders of the Students Against Discrimination Movement (SADM) recently started a campaign for a proclamation (July proclamation). It was a recent demand/discussion as previously there was no discussion on this. All of a sudden, the leaders of the SADM started to make the demand for the proclamation at the end of December 2024.

I was surprised at their demand. The recent activities of the leaders of the SADM is not inspiring and rather disappointing and it has already started to feel like they are acting like autocrats themselves.  

Accepting favor from foreign governments and general perceptions of it

Khaleda Zia went to UK for treatment and meeting her son. She went there on an Air Ambulance provided by Qatar Government and for this, the Qatar Government did not take any penny . Basically it was a gift. In Bangladeshi politics, lots of people see this a favorable things for Zia – that a foreign government allow her to use their facilities without any cost. Almost all newspaper and media cover the story.

1/11 and our amnesia

Recently BNP leader Khaleda Zia attended the Armed Forces Day reception at Senakunja in Dhaka Cantonment. In the program, she was received very warmly by the Chief Advisor Dr. Younus and others.  After the July uprising, such warm treatment of her made me feel a poignant sadness. Did we forget history too fast? Did the BAL government made us forget all of our history this fast? 

Lets check the history briefly. She was prime minister for two times and in both cases, she refused to leave the government and hold a free and fair election. In her first term, people were forced to take a street and force her down. In her second term, her action (through her president) forced the army to take power and install a caretaker government. In her second term, opposition leaders were attacked, bombed, and killed. 21 August grenade attacks happened under her government and they later try to hold a false enquiry to derail the investigation. 

Awami League paradox of Bangladesh's democracy

Let me ask you a question - in your view, who is the most qualified and democratic president of Bangladesh? If you already know the names of all presidents, then you may already know. But if you don’t, just take a look at the list and then see whom you find the most democratic president of Bangladesh. 

I can tell you by far the name you will find just one name - Justice Shahabuddin Ahmed. His independence and adherence to democratic norms is by far the most among all presidents in Bangladesh. In the list, rest of the presidents are either partisan or did not leave any mark on the democratic process of Bangladesh. He was trusted by all parties to form the first caretaker government of Bangladesh and under his presidency, the country saw the first ever free and fair election in Bangladesh. I do not think you will find any critics of him, except for certain minor issues. 

The Irony and Risks of Tajul Islam as Chief Prosecutor of ICT in Bangladesh

Recently, the current interim government of Bangladesh appointed Advocate Tajul Islam as the Chief Prosecutor for the International Crimes Tribunal (ICT), despite his previous role in defending several Jamaat-e-Islami leaders in cases before the tribunal. His appointment has raised eyebrows, although few have openly objected. This decision raises both judicial and political concerns . It seems the government has failed to learn from the mistakes of the previous administration and their public relations blunders. In fact, the appointment feels like a gift to the very regime the people just deposed.